Should I Get a Lawyer For A Car Accident That Wasn't My Fault

Josh Schwadron

Written By

Josh Schwadron

Chief Executive Officer

Reviewed by

Published On

September 20, 2024

Published On

September 20, 2024

Table of Contents
Share this Article

Quick Answer

You've been in a car accident, and it wasn't your fault. So you’re thinking? Should I get a lawyer?

Short Answer: Well it depends. There are many instances where you can submit a settlement claim without a lawyer, especially if the other driver is at-fault. But there are complex situations, where a lawyer is beneficial to your case.

When Should I Get A Lawyer For A Car Accident That Wasn’t My Fault

You might think that if you’ve been in a car accident that’s not your fault, then the situation is fairly straightforward. But the reality is often more complex. While many states operate on a no-fault insurance system, which covers your own damages regardless of who caused the accident, there are still situations where hiring a lawyer can be beneficial.

Reasons for NOT Getting a Lawyer

While hiring a lawyer can be beneficial, there are situations where handling a no-fault car accident claim on your own might be a viable option. Here are some factors to consider:

  • Minor Injuries: If your injuries are minor and your medical bills are relatively low, the costs of hiring a lawyer might outweigh the potential benefits.
  • Quick and Easy Claim: If the insurance company is cooperative and the claim process is straightforward, you may be able to handle it without legal assistance.
  • Financial Constraints: Legal fees can be expensive, and if you're facing financial hardship, hiring a lawyer might not be feasible.
  • Do-It-Yourself Confidence: Some individuals are comfortable with legal procedures and paperwork and may feel confident handling the claim themselves.
  • New Technology and Services: Innovation in technology means there are now services that are able to replace much of the work a lawyer does when submitting a claim. Such services as Mighty.com, powered by artificial intelligence can handle cases like a lawyer, but without the cost associated with hiring a lawyer. 

It's essential to weigh these factors carefully before deciding whether to hire a lawyer.

Reasons Why You Should Get a Lawyer For A Car Accident That Wasn’t Your Fault

The Accident Resulted in Significant Damage

If your car accident caused substantial damage to your vehicle, hiring a lawyer is strongly recommended. Insurance adjusters often undervalue property damage, and a skilled attorney can help you obtain fair compensation.

Furthermore, significant property damage often accompanies severe injuries. A lawyer can ensure that all damages, including medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering, are accounted for in your claim.

Legal Advice

One of the most compelling reasons to hire a lawyer after a no-fault car accident is their legal expertise. Car accident law can be complex, with specific regulations and deadlines that vary by state.

A lawyer is well-versed in these intricacies and can ensure your rights are protected.

They can provide invaluable guidance throughout the claims process, from gathering evidence and negotiating with insurance companies to representing your interests in court if necessary.

Protecting Your Rights

Insurance companies are businesses with a bottom line. Their primary goal is to minimize payouts. When you handle a claim on your own, you're essentially negotiating against a professional whose job it is to get you to settle for less.

A lawyer acts as your advocate, ensuring that your rights are protected throughout the claims process. They will challenge lowball offers, gather evidence to support your claim, and negotiate aggressively on your behalf.

Investigate The Case Well 

A lawyer brings a level of investigative expertise that the average person simply doesn't possess. They know where to look for evidence, how to gather it, and how to present it effectively.

This includes:

  • Gathering evidence: This can involve obtaining police reports, medical records, witness statements, and accident scene photos.
  • Investigating the other driver: A lawyer can look into the other driver's driving history, including previous accidents or traffic violations.  
  • Consulting experts: If necessary, a lawyer can hire experts, such as accident reconstruction specialists or medical professionals, to build a strong case.

By conducting a thorough investigation, a lawyer can significantly increase your chances of recovering maximum compensation.

Complex Settlement Negotiations

Negotiating a settlement can be a daunting task, especially when dealing with insurance companies. Lawyers are skilled negotiators who understand the tactics used by insurance adjusters. They can protect you from lowball offers and ensure you receive fair compensation for your losses.

A lawyer can also handle complex settlement negotiations, such as:

  • Structured settlements: These involve periodic payments over time, which can be beneficial for long-term care or future medical expenses.
  • Contingent fee arrangements: Many personal injury lawyers work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they only get paid if you win your case. This can alleviate financial stress during the legal process.  

By hiring a lawyer, you're gaining a skilled negotiator who will work tirelessly to achieve the best possible outcome for your case.

Full Extent of Injuries & Injuries that Aren’t Immediately Apparent

One of the most significant challenges facing car accident victims is determining the full extent of their injuries. Many injuries, such as concussions, soft tissue damage, or internal bleeding, may not be immediately apparent.

A lawyer can help by:

  • Encouraging thorough medical evaluation: They can urge you to seek comprehensive medical attention, including follow-up appointments and specialized tests.
  • Documenting injuries: A lawyer will meticulously document all your injuries, both present and future, to build a strong case for compensation.
  • Understanding the long-term implications: Some injuries, like traumatic brain injuries or spinal cord injuries, may have lifelong consequences. A lawyer can help you understand the full impact of your injuries and fight for the compensation you deserve.

It's crucial to remember that symptoms can manifest days, weeks, or even months after an accident. A lawyer will be your advocate in ensuring that all your medical needs are met and that you receive fair compensation for your suffering.

Keeping Timelines And Representing You As Necessary In Court and Meetings

Car accident cases involve strict timelines and legal procedures. Missing a deadline can have severe consequences for your claim. A lawyer is well-versed in these complexities and will ensure that all necessary steps are taken within the allotted time frame.

Additionally, while most car accident cases settle out of court, there are instances where litigation becomes necessary. A lawyer will represent your interests aggressively in court, presenting evidence, cross-examining witnesses, and arguing your case before a judge or jury.

By having a lawyer on your side, you can focus on your recovery while they handle the legal aspects of your case.

Maximizing Settlement Amount & Full Economic & Non-Economic Damages

A primary goal of hiring a lawyer is to maximize the settlement amount you receive. Lawyers have a deep understanding of the factors that influence settlement values, including economic and non-economic damages.  

  • Economic Damages: These are quantifiable financial losses resulting from the accident, such as medical bills, lost wages, property damage, and future earning potential. A lawyer will meticulously calculate these damages to ensure you receive full compensation. 
  • Non-Economic Damages: These are intangible losses, such as pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, and loss of consortium. While more difficult to quantify, a lawyer can effectively communicate the impact of these damages on your life and advocate for fair compensation.  

By thoroughly assessing your case, a lawyer can build a compelling argument for a higher settlement amount, considering both economic and non-economic factors.

Your First Settlement Claim Was Denied

While it's disappointing to have your initial settlement claim denied, it's not uncommon. Insurance companies often use denial as a tactic to reduce payouts or gather more information.

As we've discussed, hiring a lawyer can be invaluable in these situations. They understand the reasons behind claim denials and have the experience to effectively challenge them. A skilled attorney will carefully review the denial letter, gather additional evidence, and build a strong case to appeal the decision.

Remember, a denied claim isn't the end of the road. With the right legal representation, you can increase your chances of securing the compensation you deserve.

Insurance Company Is Saying The Accident Was Your Fault

One of the most frustrating tactics employed by insurance companies is blaming the accident entirely on the victim. They may claim you were speeding, distracted, or otherwise at fault to avoid paying compensation.

This is where a lawyer's expertise becomes invaluable. They can thoroughly investigate the accident, gather evidence, and challenge the insurance company's claims. This might include:

  • Analyzing the police report: Often, the police report provides crucial details about the accident, including eyewitness accounts and accident reconstruction data.
  • Gathering witness statements: Eyewitness testimony can be crucial in determining fault.
  • Consulting experts: Accident reconstruction experts or other specialists can provide valuable insights into the cause of the accident.

A lawyer will meticulously build a case to prove the other driver's negligence and protect your rights. Remember, insurance companies prioritize their bottom line, and they will often resort to aggressive tactics to minimize payouts.

State Fault Rules Complexity

One of the most significant challenges in car accident claims is navigating the complexities of state-specific fault rules. These laws determine how fault is assigned in an accident and impact who is liable for damages.

  • Varying State Laws: Each state has its unique set of rules regarding fault, making it essential to understand the specific laws where the accident occurred.
  • Comparative Negligence: Many states follow a comparative negligence system, where damages are reduced based on the percentage of fault assigned to the injured party. This can significantly impact the amount of compensation recovered.
  • Contributory Negligence: Some states still adhere to contributory negligence, meaning any fault on the part of the injured party can bar them from recovering damages altogether.

Understanding the nuances of state fault rules is crucial for building a strong case. A skilled lawyer can help you navigate these complexities and protect your rights.

No Out of Pocket Expenses

Many people believe that hiring a lawyer to handle a car accident claim means incurring significant out-of-pocket expenses. This is often a misconception.

Contingency Fee Arrangements

Most personal injury lawyers, including those specializing in car accidents, work on a contingency fee basis. This means you don't pay anything upfront or hourly. Instead, the lawyer receives a percentage of the settlement or judgment awarded in your case.

Understanding the Arrangement

It's crucial to understand the terms of the contingency fee agreement. This typically includes:

  • Percentage of the settlement: The percentage varies by law firm but is usually between 25% and 40%.
  • Costs and expenses: While you generally don't pay hourly fees, you might be responsible for certain costs, such as court filing fees or expert witness fees. However, these costs are often recoverable if you win your case.

By opting for a lawyer who works on a contingency fee basis, you can focus on recovering from your injuries without worrying about upfront legal costs.

How Much Money Should You Expect As Part of a Car Accident Settlement 

Determining the exact amount you can expect from a car accident settlement is challenging, as each case is unique. Several factors influence the final figure, including the severity of your injuries, the extent of property damage, and the applicable state laws.

Factors Affecting Settlement Amount

  • Severity of Injuries: The more severe your injuries, the higher the potential settlement. This includes both physical and emotional suffering.
  • Medical Expenses: Documentation of all medical bills, including past, current, and future costs, is crucial.
  • Lost Wages: If you missed work due to your injuries, these losses can be compensated.
  • Property Damage: The cost of repairing or replacing your vehicle will be factored in.
  • Pain and Suffering: This is a non-economic damage that compensates for physical and emotional pain.
  • Liability: The percentage of fault assigned to you and the other driver will impact the settlement amount.
  • Insurance Policy Limits: The at-fault driver's insurance policy limits can cap the potential settlement.

Understanding the Settlement Process

While the exact amount is unpredictable, it's essential to understand the general settlement process:

  1. Document Your Losses: Gather all medical bills, repair estimates, wage stubs, and other relevant documentation.
  2. Seek Medical Attention: Ensure all injuries are properly diagnosed and treated.
  3. Consult with a Lawyer: An experienced attorney can help you understand your rights and maximize your compensation.
  4. Negotiation: Your lawyer will negotiate with the insurance company to reach a fair settlement.
  5. Settlement Offer: The insurance company may make a settlement offer.
  6. Accept or Reject: You have the right to accept or reject the offer. If you reject it, the case may proceed to litigation.

Remember, these are general guidelines. The specific details of your case will determine the final settlement amount. It's crucial to consult with a qualified car accident attorney to understand your options and protect your rights.

Alternatively, check out Mighty.com to see where you stand in terms of your car accident and whether our service can help you out.

Josh Schwadron

Written By

Josh Schwadron

Chief Executive Officer

About the author

Joshua is a lawyer and tech entrepreneur who speaks and writes frequently on the civil justice system. Previously, Joshua founded Betterfly, a VC-backed marketplace that reimagined how consumers find local services by connecting them to individuals rather than companies. Betterfly was acquired by Takelessons in 2014. Joshua holds a JD from Emory University, and a BA in Economics and MA in Accounting from the University of Michigan.

Learn More

Reviewed by

About the reviewer